AP 03-02-06 Addendum No. 1SOUTH TAHOE PUBLIC UTILITY DISTRICT
"Basic Services for a Complex World"
REGULAR BOARD MEETING AGENDA ADDENDUM NO. 1
Note: This item was received subsequent to the Regular Board Meeting Agenda being posted.
Adding it to the Agenda will require a separate vote with approval by two- thirds of the
Board members present (or all Board members if less than two-thirds are present).
Thursday, March 2, 2006
2:00 P.M.
City Council Chambers
1900 Lake Tahoe Boulevard, South Lake Tahoe, California
Richard Solbrig, General Manager Paul Sciuto, Assistant Manager
Eric W. Schafer, President BOARD MEMBERS Duane Wallace, Vice President
Mary Lou Mosbacher, Director
James R. Jones, Director
Tom Comte, Director
6. ITEMS FOR BOARD ACTION
REQUESTED BOARD ACTION
c. 2:45 P.M. Public Hearing
Customer Service, Operations and
Laboratory Facility
(Jim Hoggatt)
(1) Hold a Public Hearing Regarding
the Substitution of Subcontractor;
(2) Make Written Findings
Regarding Whether the Stated
Justification for the Substitution is
an Authorized Ground for the
Substitution, and Has Been
Substantiated by the Facts
Presented; (3) Determine Whether
to Approve Substitution of a New
Roofing Subcontractor as
Requested by Roebbelen
Construction Inc.
ouch Tahoe
Public Utility District
General Manager
Richard H. Solbrig
Directors
Toni Comte
James R. Jones
Mary Lou Mosbacher
Duane Wallace
Eric Schafer
1275 Meadow Crest Drive • South Lake Tahoe • CA 96150 -7401
Phone 530 544 -6474 • Fax 530 541 -0614 • www.stpuctus
BOARD AGENDA ITEM 6c
TO: Board of Directors
FROM: Jim Hoggatt, Construction Manager /Engineer
MEETING DATE: March 2, 2006
ITEM — PROJECT NAME: Customer Service, Operations and Laboratory Facility
2:45 p.m. PUBLIC HEARING
REQUESTED BOARD ACTION: (1) Hold a Public Hearing regarding the substitution of
subcontractor; (2) Make written findings regarding whether the stated justification for the
substitution is an authorized ground for the substitution, and has been substantiated by
the facts presented; (3) Determine whether to approve substitution of a new roofing
subcontractor as requested by Roebbelen Construction Inc.
DISCUSSION: Roebbelen Construction, Inc., the general contractor for the new
buildings, has requested District approval to substitute a new subcontractor to furnish
and install the roofing for the project. The request is made pursuant to Public Contracts
Code Section 4107.
According to the general contractor, they are requesting Andy's Roofing be replaced
due to poor performance, lack of supervision, below standard quality, lack of manpower,
lack of experience /knowledge of products and installation, and safety violations, in
which the contractor outlined in their letter to Andy's Roofing dated February 24, 2006.
The contractor notified the District on February 27, 2006, that they had terminated
Andy's Roofing. District staff sent Andy's Roofing a certified letter giving them five (5)
days, from the date of receipt, to respond to the contractor's request.
Andy's Roofing, as of this date, has not officially notified District staff if they are going to
file an objection. The contractor has furnished the District a copy of a letter they
received from Andy's Roofing disputing these allegations. A copy of that letter is
attached even though the District has not received an official copy.
SCHEDULE: As soon as possible
COSTS: None
ACCOUNT NO:
BUDGETED AMOUNT REMAINING:
ATTACHMENTS: Copies of Roebbelen's Letters dated 1/26/06, 1/31/06, 2/24/06,
2/27/06; Copy of Andy's Roofing Letter dated 2/27/06
CONCURRENCE WITH REQUESTED ACTION:
GENERAL MANAGER: YES NO
CHIEF FINANCIAL OFFICER: YES NO
CATEGORY: General
ZU/ LULJU/ 111U L.W.U1 4144„
.•
.•
• '
January 26, 2006 •
Vie, vaesii:. est : •
• ..4:•..,•: 4 -- ••• ••••• • 1....• ....: .....
Aftn: Jonathan Engqmsta- .... ,.;.- .i
I.- : ..... -..... . • 5, ..... .
el. el.." 1 . •• ; . ••• • .... ••••• .t.,
• J '.• -
...Andy's Roofing Company-Ric. • .,%;.7'• :: - t:-....,. ' .
.. . . • ...« • 0 .
897 Ames Avenuetg•';:' .ii:i a :: .. .. 0... .• .
•• -•:. • - r., . 4-1.
Milpitas,. CA. 95.0.1.e.r.r . ...)..:,. •
....... , .. • ....:., ,. ...„ , ..
.. .e. • . 1 .- . • : ' ' • :".c::: • 44 .. L.
Fa . ....
x: 408-416-Obt • .. . .. .. • . .... ,: ,.7." ••1
• r .. • . . • '..:".;•.s. 41 •• •• .. • 1.••
: ' .
Slet' r•r.a. 's.fa . tti hie. ,l. iI 4•..•.a-s•.. li. •••i■re61....! e ge• . .t fPstv.uh'l""bo. le•i• XA 4 A .• . i. .. •. ; •t=• s1.':4 .b1•.* .: ..•' ... '• '- '• •• e . . t . . . • v ; ", •.•..■... r. ':.4. ;. •- • "i •"; .•.• )k , r ' ,' ...'. - •4 '" , : , .: . t iY •. :
. .• . ..• . .•:••: " : '
a.: ..:* • b . 'I; f ' •i •:•-•• •.I
-, . .. • .
., 43
. 1. .3:.p..il• vd.: . .in1.: .:...• ...•• • , r rV
Pages :E.
. j 1 ZS LV4 '.. 1 • .. • V . , *: : 4 ty i. s;. .•I • . -7• r••
•i
RE CuiuSos ProJect : . . • '. . mi:.1 . .
.
. .. •
,....
So o c Utlittri .. ; tT
: t . . .
,.. .. .
...•
.: ..
,........„,...,....../ . : . :
SUbjedW*1 t!:14..NotMeation,of 72.11/Jur Notice :::,1
.., ...... .....
...-:,:..; ..: ,:... 4.:..“.14 ...;,...; ...1,...L.. i '.. • : . "..".
.-.t : ......_.:41"i::. .?.....': : • r.' ' . ' • •-•-v I.:I"- :•.,,..; ..1.... .. .., ,
41 '..... . • .'t'?".1.1;:::••••••••:4 . ; .....::.
'•• •-• -.i.r.7.kg!' .....:7.... , :11":•.I . : . IV : to •t• • .:..:,. : ... . .....:. . 1.,... .7. .. .c. ,
Dear Jonathan:4 • -9,.. t• .: .'"'",= :' ". r
.: 0. •• • : -.Iv, - ! ••,....::•.- : : . 2: ;:` : ''' =•***.k:'-1..,:••••: 4, ..... ..
' ' • '''•*".,..•••••::',..• •,,,y,,..... .....,...,...„.....,.
•• •••.. r:::. 17:211:..
....... l';:.!;.7. ... % ,.:.
Per A,2itiele...:50';:dfAtit- sui-e6ri*iptiigreement ytFir fum is ofddialiy :p"I's.d.eti 06 ii.21:41AIr .:. ..-
14°116.z.;••:::.Yoir nn was- the customer. Frvice bul4Q 1:31;":44071!0 t6 *Vein : .. .
.. •
inS talli402;::.kour firti cliditd.tj3.e.gin installatiotismtil 1-16-O to tinti; the thiiipowOr . • ,
sippliii101.)iii project is nof.iAcreaat to rasintiii schedule. A pd ; your thi;eviri4.:••creW....
showedifici'•:wtirk to .. - .. . - ::9:30 am anAave not reCtlitrecli.:•There has be an
occasfdOW.414 snoi(i•;:41i64;.Wic..40.1y, howaver1::the project '..iiisP&444 ,autborized,.lahr...
peoplei4i.tAiginii.:7i", 0iii.;;;itag the prolect while critical worl4.i pccyrring 4 ot....,....
acceptabiongr*.st : ,. .fictipletitted.' Your fit:m*4s given (10)orliiiiit ..ci*:.q.complete'•
this rod:iialotii." .:'or*sr: .4:t00eitedule. • This .icl?edule was iii.is35ii4itY:sio,'• Airt 41.:
7-6-05. .Paiebl?eiiii-liai'liever."t ;r:fied.a.caprlientregar +ding,. t1ip...1;cheiluie L.ryp..3 ;;••o4 ..
0 . • • • •
/ ;.:. ..•... .- : 1-..: . .., , ...r .. ......-. :. .v.... ... .
.. .... . ...
• • . ..
• . .......;• :
II • • ';'7'.
Additionally,: your fora has not supplied *nate tools and equipment foi,..Your
installation:is identified in a memo sent to yon.bp 1-24. Roebbelen has continually tad
to assist 3ibir installers with equipment, tools, labor to cover your work; and snow 7 ice
removal. Yam crews continue to not cover their work or stored material to protoot it
The project inspector has stated that if the insulation and insulation board ofthe installed
/ stored material gets wet, it will be rejected. Roebbelen will not be responsible if this
happens and your ftrm will be required to replace while maintaining schedule. . • •
. . • .
. .
Roebbelen has slab been receiving several BFI's from your firm lately. This appears to
. . .
-.. some attempt at a delay tactic. Questions like these should have been answered long ago
.. .
• - • 1241 Hants Flight Court, Suite 100, El Dorado HMs, CA 95762 .- .
. . . . .
'. . Telephone: (916)939-4000 /Fax: (916) 939-4057/ General Contractors License # 734124
' : , .. - • .. . .. . . ,: ...
. . .. . ..- .. -
OEBBELE
. • . • .•
CONTRA.C714,* C... • .
1"•• • r•• •
•
•
••• • .• '41
Or.14.... • .
' ••••;%',..711
•k 4* •
. • • ...el-
prr,. • • •••••!. • • ., • `• ••••
+: ••.%
-'• •••- *: •• J • • • • • • ••%: .1: •
•r-r v"•-• .4"••••; 'et '• • 4..
RECEIVED JAN-26-06 16 :DB HOW
TO-KLEEIMN ROEBBELEN
PAGE.
•
' .•JUU/ luv UJ•ULtnt•,'uVLLLLLL'I1'
1 -AA 11 V. _ Y..uu:d vUL
before installation started. You stated in •a response that your fin has been delayed in
the start ,of your work. If this is the case, why are these late questioDs coming if your.:
fist was ready to start some time ago.
Please correct these problems immediately and supplement your crew to finish your work
as scheduled. .Failure to comply will result in Roebbelen supplementing your crew with
another contractor at your contract's expense.
•
. sincerely,
ROEBBELEN CONTRACTING, INC.
Sean Honegger
Project Manager
cc: Jobsite
RECEIVED JAN-26 -06 16:06 FROM- TO- KLEEMAN ROEBBELEN PAGE 02
Y ip, 6 ! .. t! F •C t i 3 _..� . '! .�'ti;, ..y
Roebbe ' - r" • • in re nse to our 1-264, 6 .2, our aio
.16 h •1 , 4 Va++ ` t i 4 i .r}.'t3t 4M :s.
r ° axons why fhis`inot ce is n -._
,�t , .1E, oeb�fmds no valid Y rio , y �
review, .z. .:
basca
'".- delayed our testa pad, z° h ia.ai• -.
�. �••�.. 'A t' chelen has Y 4 •. _ ,x
Seem. � �,_ °•�t� ..n.t :: �� t P t '!F h -@ i 7P . @@'
on 4 • � % ' ' ` our subcontract agreement all ;1
I will foil -.-1.. t ay claims. (1)Or subcon.. eemi :0 early z
� �aele
Roe elen: 6.;.e :.g Inc. scledul.e as aided
• "Adheres � .. .,_ �• � „
�nne as outline in bid documents. Add
ona l
Con • • • , € . onsite field • .4.- c ,
t. our subconraC
your c rit o •I firrll, .. „�„• tt tom;.° .. .vision for elays. A edsu on m cL
ntractor s progress
.contractor
s•
u o ...Ism
January31, 2006
Via Vacsimile
Attn: Jonathan Engquist
Andy's Roofing Company, Inc. •
897 Ames Avenue ::
Milpitas, CA 95035
Fax: 408- 416-0301
Pages: 34i,
•
, Building Project
Operation / Laboratory. g
RE: Customer�ma*�ce Facility and?�astewater
South 1a oaTublic UtilityDistrjot
South Tahoe, CA
Subject , tus of.Worksvath 72 HourNotice
D
ees that the. C - „ � r
" r' the ContractoL `b "r ti
mode � t teA t ed necessary,by_
:. t di cations as to as` h ca of
be ob . y i`�e„;fer t.'o ehy� t . or 's modifications . �� s schedule e' a m' e ” •'
nth the pro�res Xr
rerrr�in tF � .,r �.t�� c .at t� • ��re.�ffiC
' , rums 13- cA „n'o o .
documents. " schedu� does
no o r i g i n a l • o c u m e n t s t h a t ` • t@
s h e d • .t t... ons a original
" y`� eting in December.e
show your . R beginning in unit, er an: rap .410;
.. lation bePj � ,��.
Tahoe, then ,are measurable amounts of snow�fall.'at all times of the year The venter
' '� °' May 1$t This winter peso is
period in .t area starts October 150i and remains until M ��.
"'� point I am malarig rs
published�by TRPA, the governing authority intake Tahoe. The p
that we are expected to receive snow at this time of theyear. � clear of this is rest of
October '04. This area received approximately 4-5' of
the '04 — '05 winter season. When your firm bid this project to Roebbelen, your firm
r
should have anticipated adverse weather conditions as they are typical for the time of
year your installation was scheduled. • You have also clearly stated that your firm will
seek reimbursements for your non - productive work. Roebbelen will not entertain any
1241 Hawks Flight Court, Suite 100, El Dorado Dills, CA 95762
Telephone: (916) 939 - 4000 /Fax: (916) 939 -4057/ General Contractors License # 734124
• costs submitted by Andy's Roofing for delays to your work.
•
•
As shown in the CPM schedule, your work is critical to this project. Many of our
subcontractors are being impacted by the lack of weather protection on the roof If the
progress of your work continues and your firm goes way over the allotted time,
Roebbelen may be forced to deal with impacts front other subcontractors. These impacts
will be forwarded to your office should the installation of your work not progress per
schedule.
Again, the purpose of the 72 hour notice is because your firm continues to not provide
adequate manpower for installation. Please refer to the photo attached. The area covered
is not even one quarter of the building. Your installation begun on 1- 23-06, there is (1)
snow day established during this period, 1- 27 -06. Your firm has only worked (4) days
out of the possible (6) through today. 1 will remind you that our superintendent directed
your firm to proceed on 1 -12-06 with installation. Again, your firm did not start
installation until 1- 23 -06.
Your firm also continues to send RFI's regarding installation problems that should have
been sent long ago. The recent RFI 1#5 regarding EDPM installation is an example.
Regardless if you were installing in October or January, this problem would still be an
issue. if your firm was truly ready to install, these questions should have been addressed
long ago, not at the time of installation.
Please take this letter seriously as Roebbelen cannot tolerate any more delays. Your firm .
is required, per contract; to staff this project as to maintain our project schedule. • The
current crew your firm has provided is not adequate. Please send additional qualified
installers as to progress on. this critical.work. Today, is our subcontractor coordination.
meeting. This meeting is weekly. on Tuesday's at 1:30. Your firm, by contract, is
required to have,a representative, with decision making authority. :This would be very
helpful to Roebbelen, as we have had difficulty communicating with your crew.
The 72 hour notice sent to your firm on. 1-26-05 has expired. At this time, Roebbelen
may supplement your work forces if the progress of your work does not improve. Please
remedy these problems immediately. Roebbelen is more than willing to work with your
firm. We have made every attempt to allow your crew to be productive by clearing snow,
heating the deck, covering roof areas, and allowing use of our equipment Roebbelen will
continue to do this, provided your firm does your part to install the work per schedule.
Dave .or myself are available anytime to discuss, but most important to Roebbelen is to
get your work installed and all problems will be resolved.
Sincerely, ,
ROEBBELEN CONTRAC'T'ING, INC.
Sean Honegger
• Project Manager.
t, •
PAO( pgdSS 11AS 04.14? Occ-oLeD 7 -ittc: Pattf
ti-c-ot4) SKYLI&IfTS AM) ADE e/i wateKra. oft) Atik) •
Q B SELE
CC 11ZA q7 ETC.'
:4
•
February 24, 2006
`is CejaHlectitiall and Vac & .,.
• Alta: Mr. Jonathan Efiggl ist" .
.Andy's Roofing Goxnpax y, Inc. .. •:
897 Ames Aventi4t• ". i.,:. r "I - , _ r•. •
.••� CA r ,...'.t •8 .::
Fae: .408-416081 f ?' . .
RE: liriw0000'u�sr.Sezvlce h ty mood Westew;Iii Vpeintioa:/ r abo:ra1oary di •,Ptojtcc:
• sout_ "+-id ai. z � •y' ••: • • t .1 ,«" .r••.• .'t'M
r ••+;
Sean Honegger
Project Managcr
cc: Jobsitc .
Mr. Jim Hogged, STPUD 530 -541 -0614
Mr. Sam Chamberlin, DEZD Roofing 775 -685 -5566
RECEIVED FEB -24 -08 18:0T FROM- TO- KLEEW►N ROEBBELEN PACE 02
OEBBELE
CONTRACTING, INC.
February 27, 2006
Via Hand
Attn: Jim Hoggatt
South Lake Tahoe Public Utility District.
1275 Meadow Crest Drive
South Lake Tahoe, CA 96150
•
RE: Customer Service Facility and Wastewater rOperation I Laboratory Building Project
South Tahoe Public Utility. District
South Lake Tahoe, CA
Subject Replacement of Subcontractor, Andy's Roofing Company, Inc.
Dear Jim,
As you are aware by a letter copied to you on 2- 24 -06, Roebbelen has terminated our
subcontract agreement with Andy's Roofing Company, Inc. per California Public
Contract Code Section 4107.a.7. There are several reasons for this termination as
outlined in the letter from Roebbelen to Andy's Roofing dated 2- 24 -06. Also included
with this letter is supporting correspondence from Roebbelen • to Andy's Roofing
throughout the project. Roebbelen has already been damaged by the performance of
Andy's Roofing, it is our opinion that if Roebbelen continues with Andy's Roofing, the
project will be damaged further
Roebbelen has made `arrangements with another contractor that is very well suited for this
project : This new contractor'will correct the deficiencies of Andy's Roofing and resume
installation of all roofing activities including :installation of the copper sheetmetal at the
roof. ' This new contractor 'is'well versed on installation in this area and was an original
bidder to Roebbelen before the project began.'
� a v
Listed Subcontractor.;::'
Andy's Roofing Company,
897 Ames Avenues
Milpitas, CA 95035"
Ph: 408 - 416-0300
Fax: 408 -416 -0301
License' /go. 521860
Contact:; Jonathan Engquist
1241 Hawks Flight Court, Suite 100, El Dorado Hills, CA 95762
Telephone: (916) 939=4000 / Fax: (916) 939 - 4057 / General Contractors License # 734124
Replace with New Contractor
D &D Roofing and Sheet Metal, Inc.
1000 Glendale Ave.
Sparks, NV 89431
Ph: 775- 685 -5555
Fax: 775- 685 -5566
License: 486667
Contact Sam Chamberlin
Please confirm in writing that our substitution request is approved. If you have any
additional questions, please call.
Sincerely,
ROEBBELEN CONTRACTING, INC.
Sean Honegger
Project Manager
cc: Jonathan Engquist, Andy's Roofing 408 -416 -0301
Andy's Roofing Company Inc.
February 27, 2006. .
Sean Honegger •
Roebbelen Contracting, inc.
1241 Hawks Flight Court
El Dorado Hills, CA .95762
916/939 -4000
916/939 -2966' fax •
530/541 -1362 job
530/541 -2086 job fax
•
RE: South Lake Tahoe Public Utility District Customer Service Facility and
Wastewater Operations / Laboratory Building
South Lake Tahoe . . •
• Job #2659 . . • .
Subject: .. Roebbelen lettei dated February 24, 200'6
Teriiiiriatioii•of Subcontract
Dear Sir.
GK
We are very sufprised tb rfy'Celve this letter. Since your letter dated January 26, 20b6 We•have
completed the Wont tn'the areas that were ready fprout work with the +ix'isptian •of tkd :flat,ares at the
Customer SeMCe Buiiding which is pending material stibmittal revIeW. To date,.we Have hot received
specific refet bces.tfs "pootperformance, lack of supervisibh, below staiidatd- gUality", "lacI bf
e perieficeiknOWletIge•iif phiduots a hd.instsudtion, elhd safety violation":. tiiihert• We.16st:spoka :on
February 2, you•adrriitied Mitt there rtteybe-sortiti Uhtftithe tb your 72 -hour notice lst*tiiat•.yau had to
put'everything in It fer.ftiture•use against u35. The issues mentioned in yobr.72 =flout Flatlet :Ws*.
ad dr6ssed"withodt t`esptittie in -bur letter dated February 3, 2008. We considet d tf1 s issue bloaed.
Pleases fdr* 1d your suppetting docurnente9tlonior.atiy of the issues mentiohed: btive ffi:'.dUrteview.
' As far the lack df Ma(ipower° We addressed this issue by• sencdirtg •outiwice•thie•Wotlifi6rt a.:it
should be rioted,thafegch•thtiugh we wsre raver behihd e;ttiedUle, We offered oh tWo•bccasionshtb.
work Saturday ottly to be told that iRoebbe3len couldn't Piave. er yorte there to.bpen tiia site. -
We tine it •iiiinto theft :you t• idte • Safety violatient••as one .of the•feasons for this tettnitiatiori when all
/brig, Roebl eleir.he; beers pushing us to wofk in imsate bonditionst Not only have vice not. reeelved'
• a single nbtIcl df:vidiet(dh brit Cat OSHA's Cod e:o'F'iRigulations prepItides.*orRe s f om•beitig
• required sir knoyvittly ball httt'to work uridtar tir1 afie oortditloiikt. It i :u$f td.the .efliblOyet to ri ke.•
that de*termiiiatidh. Cla9rfyi; tfying:tc walk'rrfub i IsSS'Wbrk oh d 13'AridNtrik trWitft'tFie.presence o1^' •
snow sited he IS 'hat safe ho mettai• •hoW •rnehy•safety Iifie§ dh'e *ears. •
• •
We .are currently waiting for the copper to be Installed so we can start the shingle installa• tion. Your
(told staff said that this could take as Jong as a week until we could retum to. the site. We have
received no notification that this sheet metal has been completed. We don't need muchmetal
installed ahead of us to get started. 1 don't know/why this is taking so Tong. .
We can and will complete this project once the design issues are addressed and approved. There is
nothing to do on the project currently. We believe this Termination to be without cause and may Just
be a way for Roebbelen to get us off the job and hire some one cheaper to install the roofing and
copper fleshings as a package. This has been Roebbelen's intent since before we started work as
demonstrated in their letters dated September 8, 2005 and September 27, 2003.
897 Ames Avenue.- Milpitas, CA 25035 • Phone (408) 416 -0300 • Fax (408) 4160301
RECEIVED •FEB-27-06 17:17. FR011-4064160301
TO- KLEEiAAN ROEBBELEN PAGE 01
Sean Honegger
February 27, 2006
Page 2
We would request that we be allowed to meet with the Owner and our manufacturer's representatives
to ensure the Owner of the quality of our installation to date and in the future.
Please advise if we calf meet this week to resolve these and.any other concerns you might have.
enc
cc: Jim Haggett
WO
Jon - an W. Engquis
Project Manager
RECEIVED FEB- 27 -06 1T:1T FROM- 4084160301 TO- KLEEIWAN ROEBEELEN
PAGE 02
SEP ^11-D5 1L:55
FR01.1- 6LEEIMR MUM
E(EM
September 27, 201DS.
Via Pm:31.2,11s
Attu: Jim Hoggait
South Lake 'robot t Public Utility District
1275 Meadow Cist Drive
South Lake Talho , CA 96150
FM 530- S41.0614
11S-1111-11:1
1-611 r.viret r19t
OEBBELEN
CONTRACTING, INC.
Pages: 1
RE: Customer trice Facility and Wastewater Operatioo /Laboratory.
Building Project
Sauth Tah Public Utility Dbuict
South Lakt Tahoe, G
Subject C Request to Replace Roofing Contractor
Jim:
Previously, R belen Contracting regtaested the Disnicr allo* us to replace the listed
roofing contract Andy's Roofag. After further review, it appears the differences
betiyeett Andy's, Roofing and Roebbelen will be worked art. Roebbelen cancels our
request to tt pia this subcortnaetoe. Please call ifyon have any questions.
•
•
Sincerely, .
ROEBR ELEN • PJTRACTING, INC.
Sean loeegger
?reject Mauager
CC: John Engqiiisr 650-967-2741
1 41 Hawks Pligla Ceara, Sake 100, El Dorado Hilb, CA 95762
Tekpbone: ( 16) 939 -4000 / FA= (916) 939-4097/ General Contractors Licence to 734124
RECEIVED FEB -27-06 1T:17
FROM- 4084160301
TO- KLEEMIN ROEBBELEN
PAGE 03
'JEf-iB -us 14 :eV
Sepiecriiber 27, 205
•
Yid Vacsimile
Attn: Jonathan Ebggnisc .
any, Inc.
Road
94041 •
1 •
Andy's Roofing
X40 South Wh
Mountain View,
Fax: 650 -967 -2
Pages: 2 :
%RE: Customer mice Facility and Wastewater Operation / La'- oratory Building Project
South Tah Public Milky Dierriet
South La Tahoe, CA
Subject: ntraet and Cbauge Order
Dear Jonathan:
Rncbbelen has Vidsed the owner that we have withdrawn our request to replace your
firm on this FOOT- Per our discussion,1 have still not seen a price for the roof copper
sheet metal yet. On bad 'indicated in our converse:ioal drat I would receive this price by
last week. P provide puce thr ibis added work. We would like m get this work
under.contsacd d get submigalsin for approval quickly.
Our contracts eot wM he returned to your company shortly. It will be approved
and signed and t ' letter serves as your permission to proceed. Also attached is a copy
of change order #1. This is for the demo and replacerntat of the roof et the chlorin:
building. I Wt ' message at -your office Tat we would like to schedule this work next
week.. .Please vs know ,,if shot praseats a problem. Our supetintendcnt, Dave
Champion, wal contact you today or tomorrow to schedule this work.
Roebbelea has a mfnned that the roof as the customer service building will be ready for
your work the week of December. Please umrk this on your calendar and make score
that this start ek e will fit in your schedule. As you are aware, the Tahoe region weather
can be very unpctable. Your firm wilt be expected to work in adverse conditions.
Please let us bar immediately if this presents a problem.
Sincere ly
ROEB B)(.LEN ONTRACTINC. INC.
Scan Honegger
Project Manage
1 41 Rsw% Flight Court, Sake 1DD, El Dorado Rills, CA 95762
Telephone. 6),39 -0100 / Fax: (916) 939 - 4951/ General Cennaeeon Lkense u 734124
RECEIVED FEB -27 -06 17:17 FROM- 4084160301
TO- KLEEIMN ROEBBELEN PAGE 04
•
Scptranber 8, 200S
Via Ventimlle
Ann: Jonathan Engquist ..
Andy's Roofing Company, Inc.
140 South Whfsmaa Road
Mountain View, CA 94041
Fax: 6S0- 967 -2741
Pages: 1
RE: Csbiomer SeMoe Facility and Wastewater Operation 1 Laiwstety libMiag Project
South Tahoe Public Utility Dlsuta
South Lake Tahoe. CA
• Subject: Contract
Dear Jonathan:
Roebbelei has received the awned contract offered to your fiats minding the etbove
rafereaood project. Your firm has mask several modifications TO this contract in both the
main body (tee and conditions) of the omIuaet and the Altachmant A (scope of work)
portion. Raebbek v does not agree with the changes made to Irk o tract in both scope
of work and thus' of the contract. The changes made to this contact are simply too vast
for Rocbbelen so consider. Please rernembet; Roebbeletl's standard contract was
available for wriest by your firm prior to the bid of this project. If our contract was not
ro your salita5a;6on, your bid should have contained t70:11114003 10 our mnnaet as w allow
Roebbele n am opportunity to assess maid exclusions prior to bid.
Because of the inability to execute a muTm lly agreeable eaatracr. Roebbelea 1te't by
rescinds our offer to eater into s contract with your firm for this project. It is our
tmdtrstawd ng that your firm has incurred some asinsiaisatmive costs associated with this
project. Please sabtnft an Itemized bz k4 m of thews costs fir R.oebbelen to review.
You may fax the costs to myself at 916- 939 -2968. More call if yarn have questions.
Sincerely,
NOFRMEN CONTRACTING, INC.
Sean Honegger
Project Manager
cG Jinn %log r n _ South Tahoe Public Utili y District — 330 -54) O l 4
1241 Hawks Flight Court, State Okla Dara4a Rills, Ca 9576t
Telephone. (916) 939 -4000 / Firc (976) P39 -4U571 General Cowuactenr license 1R 734124
•
RECEIVED. FEB -2T -06 1T:1T
FROM-40841 60301
TO-KLEEMAN ROEBBELEN PAGE 05